At the next coven meeting, Eric interrupts and attacks Marnie. To ward him off the coven cast a spell causing him to have total memory loss. ("You Smell Like Dinner")
Marnie Stonebrook awakens unable to remember cursing Eric. Lafayette Reynolds tells the coven that they need to make amends, or Eric will kill them all for what they have done. The coven members decide that they need to fight back to preserve their freedom of religion. ("If You Love Me, Why Am I Dyin'?")
When Marnie begins to drag Holly, along with the rest of the witches into her vampire-hating army, Holly leaves the coven, uncertain if Eric and his vampire clan would attack her and her children. However, she is later convinced by Tara Thornton to participate in a ritual that would cause all of the vampires in Bon Temps to unwillingly walk out into the sun.
Andy and Holly have a farcical first date. He brings her Winn-Dixie flowers that he got on sale and is in the midst V withdrawal. He ends up dashing out of the bar with his sale flowers still in hand.
Holly is convinced to return to the coven by Tara; Tara tells her that Marnie has become more powerful by uniting with the spirit of Antonia Gavilán de Logroño and needs their help to fight back against the vampires. Antonia/Marnie, Tara and the Coven assemble. They cast Antonia's spell instilling an irresistible urge to meet the sun in nearby vampires. It begins to take effect. ("Cold Grey Light of Dawn")
At Moon Goddess Emporium Marnie/Antonia is frustrated that her spell killed only a single Vampire. She wants to exterminate all vampires. Tara wants to see the vampires gone as well. Bill calls for Antonia and asks for a meeting to resolve the situation. They arrange to liaise inside the Bon Temps Cemetery at midnight.
The witches and vampires face off in the graveyard. The situation escalates as Marnie/Antonia reveals that she's not alone and has brought her whole coven. Bill is joined not only by Eric and Sookie but also his human commandos as well as a number of vampires.
Sookie senses Marnie/Antonia casting a spell in her mind and warns Bill. Eric reacts by killing Beverleen, shocking both factions. Antonia counters by chanting a spell which causes thick fog to flood the graveyard. Amongst the haze the battle begins. During the fighting, Bill is incapacitated with silver by Holly and Roy. ("Spellbound")
At the Moon Goddess Emporium, the coven yells at Antonia because she brought Eric back with her. She tells them that he is under her control. Tara is angry at her for rejecting Bill's peace offering and causing needless violence. Antonia tries to make them hold hands to cast a protection spell. When they refuse, she plots her next move against the vampires and orders the others not to leave. Tara and Holly have misgivings. When Tara tries to leave the doorknob burns her hand. ("Let's Get Out of Here")
Casey and the other witches discuss the lack of phone reception, still trying to escape captivity. Meanwhile, Tara and Holly are hatching a plan to undo Martonia’s spell. Martonia then barges in and the witches say that she can't keep them prisoner.
Tara and Holly chant a ritual to break the protection spell. They run outside to Sookie and Lafayette. Just as they are reunited Marnie makes them all disappear. Jason is left alone outside Moon Goddess. ("Burning Down the House")
Eric, Pam, Bill, and Jessica prepare to blow up Moon Goddess Emporium. Holly, Jesus, Lafayette, Sookie, Tara and the other Witches are inside. All of them are terrified except for Marnie. She calmly insists that her spell will protect them and jokes about the situation. Her attitude causes Casey to get mad and attack her. Marnie, defending herself, flings a knife at her magically, killing her. Jesus goes to Casey and tells everyone that she still has a pulse. He pleads with Marnie to let him try to heal her. She allows him, and he and Lafayette carry Casey's body to the bathroom, actually planning to use her corpse in a spell to draw Antonia away from Marnie. Holly and Sookie persuade Marnie to negotiate with the Vampires outside. She agrees, as long as Sookie goes with her.
The negotiations are unsuccessful and Marnie becomes desperate. She tells her coven that they need to band together if they are going to survive the vampire attack. Reluctantly, the others join her in a circle, even Sookie. Marnie casts a spell which causes the vampires to walk towards the shield, which will kill them. Using her fairy powers, Sookie breaks the spell, causing Marnie to believe that Sookie is trying to cross her. She causes everyone apart from Sookie to become stuck to the wall, and she creates a fire ring, trying to burn Sookie. Lafayette sees this and he gets Jesus to speed up the process of breaking Antonia out of Marnie's body. He does so, manifesting the demon's head again, with moments to spare. Antonia's spirit casts her own spell, and the fire ring around Sookie dissolves, as does the spell holding everyone to the walls. Marnie cries in despair, seeing her grand scheme falling to pieces.
Outside, the vampires see the protection shield go down. Bill and Eric rush inside Moon Goddess to kill everyone, but Sookie stops them, telling them that the majority of people in there were being held hostage by Marnie. Bill aims a gun at Marnie but Roy stands in her way, saying they'll have to go through him to get to Marnie. Eric rushes up to him and pulls his heart out, sucking the blood from it like a straw in front of a horrified Marnie. Bill then takes aim at Marnie, who berates Bill saying "Nobody lives forever - not even you!" As the words leave her mouth, Bill shoots Marnie multiple times, including a final shot into her forehead. ("Soul of Fire")
After the death of Marnie, Lafayette is possessed by her undying spirit. Holly was able to rescue Lafayette by calling upon the spirits of the dead to free Marnie of her anger, and to help her find peace. At Merlotte's, Andy gives Holly some flowers, apologizing for the disaster at their date and admitting that he was on V. Holly forgives him and says that, "I need a hug" and Andy gives her one. ("And When I Die")